Table 1 below summarizes the classification and description of the FFF process chain cases that were found during the case analysis of the research:
Figure 1 summarizes the FFF process chain case subclassifications obtained from the previous table and during the analysis of cases.
Figure 2 summarizes the general DF-FFF methodology with process chain.
Figure 2 shows the methodology steps grouped by the different phases of the design process. The following explains the steps in Figure 2 grouped by each design phase.
Task clarification (TC). At the end of this phase, the lists of requirements, criteria, or specifications/properties of the product to be developed will be obtained. For this purpose, the following steps must be followed:
a)Search within the database (DB) for the general case to which the product to be designed belongs according to one of the eight cases described in Table 1.
b)Within the general case, the specific case is searched according to the products described in Figure 1.
c)If the specific or similar product is not found in the DB, it is possible to:
d)Once a DB case matching the desired product is found, the list of requirements is displayed with the specifications defined for the DB case, and based on these, the product is defined for its own product.
Conceptual Design (CD). At the end of this phase, several initial CD will be obtained, and the selection of one or more will be based on requirements or criteria. For this purpose, the following steps should be followed:
a)Search for a combination of materials and specific FFF process parameters to meet the initial specifications.
b)If a feasible FFF alternatives is found or not, considering:
Look for correspondence between the requirements and specifications of the alternatives to ensure compliance with requirements.
c)Define selection criteria based on the requirements and specifications set in the CT phase.
d)Assign a weighting to the criteria obtained in this phase based on the objectives pursued, market statistics, and quantitative figures.
e) Establish quantitative characteristics of the alternative per criterion using the DB.
f) Evaluate and select the alternative using the weighted criteria matrix (WCM) method. In this phase, the consultation of the DB and specialized bibliography is used to quantify properties to evaluate and select the best alternative based on objective variables.
Basic Design (BD). At the end of this phase, the BD of the product will be obtained, that is, the rules and process to modify the DC, the modified DC to a shape close to the final shape, and the specific manufacturing process to be used. To this end, the following steps must be followed:
a)Search for the most suitable design rules.
b)Analyze and study the rules or methods by consulting the original references (framework) and apply them to the CD to transform the concept to a basic form according to the requirements.
c)Verify the level of concordance between the primary forms and the requirements and use the DB.
d)If different basic processing and design forms were generated accordingly, based on properties and requirements, a WCM evaluation would be required to select the BD and its processing form.
Design in Detail (DD). At the end of this phase, the final digital model and the specifications and process parameters will be obtained. For this purpose, the following steps must be followed:
a)In the DB and specialized bibliography, search for the information, model, or program that helps to specify the product property.
b)Appropriate in the use of models or CAD (Computer Aided Design) /CAM (Computer Aided Manufacturing) programs to apply to DB and transform it into DD. Including:
c)Use the data and models to simulate and modify the design performance until it conforms to the requirements through an iterative process. Use WCM in the most demanding cases.
d)Generate design specifications by exporting:
On the other hand, in case of redesigning parts manufactured with FFF, whose properties do not conform to the desired specifications, the steps in Figure 3 should be followed:
The following explains the steps in Figure 3:
References
[1] L. L. Lopez Taborda, H. Maury, and J. Pacheco, “Design for additive manufacturing: a comprehensive review of the tendencies and limitations of methodologies,” Rapid Prototyp. J., vol. 27, no. 5, pp. 918–966, Jun. 2021.
[2] Luis Lisandro Lopez Taborda et al. Design methodology for Fused Filament Fabrication with process chain: framework, Knowledge base/database, methodology. Universidad del Atlántico, Universidad del Norte, 3D Ingenieria BQ SAS, Barranquilla, Colombia, 2024.